Tyrese Haliburton

The Knicks thought they had it won. Up 17 in the fourth quarter. The home crowd on its feet. But Tyrese Haliburton had other plans. After helping engineer one of the wildest playoff comebacks of the season, Haliburton caps it off with a cold-blooded step-in jumper from just inside the arc as time expires—tying Game 1 of the Eastern Conference Finals and forcing overtime. As the ball drops through the net, Haliburton turns toward the crowd and delivers a ruthless "choke" taunt, silencing Madison Square Garden and punctuating a 33-point, 11-assist masterclass. Indiana rides the wave into OT and steals the series opener on the road.